What should you do if you shoot a world record whitetail

World Record Whitetail photoshop fake

You wake up early in the morning and just have that feeling something good is going to happen.  Your dream of that world record whitetail just might happen.  It’s that same dream all deer hunters have had either laying in bed the night before a hunt or while you’re sitting in the stand.  We’ve all had that dream of the ground shaking and seeing trees topple as the antlers on the buck of your dreams are so big, nothing can stand in their way.  This monster buck walks down that trail you’ve been hoping for and is heading right for that one spot you imagine deer walking thru every time you climb that tree.  Your heart is about to explode out of your chest and you don’t remember how long it’s been since you’ve taken a breath of air.  The wind is just right as you draw back that bow and release. The arrow flies as true as can be and hits right where you were aiming.  That buck of the century runs 30 yards and drops.  Everything is perfect.  (I bet you thought the arrow was going to hit a limb and miss or something, right?) You sit in your stand in disbelief and just think how your dreams have come true.  But, has your nightmare’s just begun?

If you’ve been hunting long, we’ve all seen several “world record whitetail” pop up only to have them followed quickly by ridicule and accusations for some sort of wrongdoing.  Sadly, this has become the norm and for good reason and of 95% of the time, it’s true.  But this monster buck you just shot is totally legal and everything is done right.  You have nothing to worry about right? Wrong!!  As soon as you post a pic online, there will be haters and finger pointers saying you did something wrong.  We are living in a guilty until the proven innocent world and we have to prove everything to everyone.  If you really want to tell everyone about this deer or try and become “famous” from this deer, let me give you a few hunting tips to make your life a lot easier with your new trophy buck.

The following is my response to the hunters that want to tell the world about their deer and maybe reap the rewards that may follow.  I know many of you may not care about any of that, therefore, won’t worry about it.  If that is you, then I hope you at least let the deer be seen but just keep every bit of details about it hidden.

The first thing to do after shooting a World Record Whitetail

First off, do not post any pictures to anyone yet.  Not even your best bud or your sister. You need to treat this as if you just found a dead body in your backyard.  Your first instinct should be to call the authorities and “prove your innocence” before any accusations are even made.  It’s sad, I know.  But this is how this world has become.  But I’m not saying to call the FBI and get CSI out there to inspect the scene, but just call the local game warden and explain the situation.  He/She should understand the circumstances and realize that the deer needs to be processed quickly so they should be able to get to you quickly and verify that everything is totally legal and you are good to go.

Document everything

This is the time to where you hope had that video camera rolling.  Not because you can’t wait to upload it to YouTube and start to become famous, but because it’s proof of where you were when you took the shot.  Start taking pics of everything with every distinct landmark in the background.  Again, I wish I didn’t have to say this, but you will have to prove your innocence and it will be very important if you really do have the next world record whitetail.

Get a lawyer

So, everything has checked out and you’ve been cleared by the game warden.  Now is the time to start thinking about your future.  You just won the deer hunter’s lottery and with that comes a lot of people knocking down your door wanting to see that deer and potentially pay you to do that.  You could literally be spending the next 20 plus years doing nothing but traveling around the country with your deer stopping at every sporting goods store and hunting expo showing off your deer.  With all of that, comes deals, contracts, and people trying to buy your deer, buy your molds and trying to rip you off.  Play it safe and be protected.

What you do with your trophy is totally up to you.  These are just my suggestions if you want everyone to know about it and be recorded with having and biggest buck ever.  Personally, I don’t think I would do anything with the deer other than contacting Boone & Crockett so they could record the deer for conservation purposes only. I would post pics about it but only without me in them and I would say the deer was harvested in Canada or somewhere far away from where I was hunting.  But if you do find that dream has come true and want to take full advantage of winning that lottery, please consider my advice above.  I’ve seen too many good hunters be torn down and ripped apart by trolls.

Leave a comment and let me know what you would do if that dream came true.


  • Heather B September 8, 2016 at 4:20 pm

    Unfortunate, but true! We live in a world plagued with vicious vegans & extreme animal rights activists who place the value of animals above human beings. The best ones are those who actually eat meat daily, yet condemn hunters as “cruel”, “evil” and “monsters”, sometimes even wishing death upon us (And WE are the evil ones???). I’m guessing that these hypocrites believe their t-bone steak comes from the magical beef fairy in the sky? Amazing how they feel that hunting a free-roaming animal, void of nasty antibiotics, steroids and preservatives, is the epitome of evil…Yet, they have no problem stuffing their faces with the grocery store meat that was bred for the sole purpose of slaughter, often living in confined spaces, rolling around in their own filth. If I shoot a record whitetail buck, I will do what any proud hunter would do: Smile from ear-to-ear, call in the troops to help drag it out of the woods, pose with it until my body hurts, bring the head to a reputable taxidermist, have it butchered and enjoy every single morsel. I would face these trolls like a warrior and rightfully tell them to go **** them selves! 🙂

  • Matt Staser September 8, 2016 at 4:27 pm

    Heather. The extremist aren’t really the issue with a lot of this. It’s the jealous hunters out there that can’t stand someone else succeeding. Those are the ones that will troll and point out every possible scenario of that dream being fake or taken illegally. Again, this is just another case to where we are our own enemies.

  • Keith Lilly September 12, 2016 at 4:14 pm

    I agree Matt it is sad even hunters attacking other hunters of the different methods used to harvest a trophy. as long it is legal they should be supporting them. The bunny huggers would like nothing more than hunters attacking one another giving the trolls more ammo to use against us. Matt I wish a good season for you hope all of yours are trophies

  • Robert Faris II September 13, 2016 at 1:48 pm

    Plus If you let it be known where you got it , every place close enough to you will be leased up! This happened to me years ago, now I don’t tell a soul about my deer and don’t even get them officially scored! Plus all your hunting friends will hate you!

    • Matt Staser September 13, 2016 at 2:34 pm

      Robert, All of that is becoming more and more common with a lot of hunters.

  • Mike November 10, 2016 at 3:44 pm

    Thinking about purchasing a crossbow total beginner

  • Pockets... always carry a pocket knife N1 | N1 Moments from N1 Outdoors March 9, 2018 at 2:47 pm

    […] dropped in his tracks. I was still unsure of exactly what I had killed. In my mind, I knew it was a big buck, I just wasn’t sure how big. I waited about 10 minutes. Without so much as a kick out of him, I […]

  • Jermy November 26, 2018 at 11:00 am

    Photo shopped much lol. you forgot to cover the antler sticking out behind the fake one lol.

    • Matt Staser November 26, 2018 at 11:36 am

      Yes, it was obviously photoshopped and meant to look fake. Kinda the point.

  • Trey Hutchinson May 9, 2019 at 1:48 pm

    My biggest is a 5×5 but it was my first ever buck


Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Salt Life